Why Is Alcohol Legal but Not Marijuana?
People ask it as “why is alcohol legal but not weed,” and the honest answer is not that alcohol is safe. Alcohol is legal because it has been part of Western culture for thousands of years and more than half of American adults drink. Society is stuck with it. The 178,000 Americans it kills each year are what happens when an addictive drug is legal, commercialized and used by most adults. Marijuana is nowhere near that, and the lesson of alcohol is to not repeat it.
Read the video transcript
Why is alcohol legal but not marijuana? It’s not because alcohol is safe. Excessive drinking kills about 178,000 Americans every year. That’s what happens when an addictive drug is legal, commercialized and used by most adults. Alcohol is legal because it’s been part of Western culture for thousands of years. Nearly half of Americans drank last month. About 15 percent used marijuana. We can’t remove a drug most adults use. We don’t have to commercialize a new one. And marijuana isn’t a safer alcohol. Daily use of high-potency marijuana carries nearly five times the odds of a psychotic disorder. Today’s THC is four times stronger than in 1995. It doesn’t replace drinking, either. More than three in four marijuana users also drink. As SAM’s president Kevin Sabet puts it: “That’s like saying my headlights are broken, and just to be consistent, I’m going to break my tail lights, too.” The lesson of alcohol is not to repeat it.
Alcohol is not legal because it is safe
The argument goes: alcohol is worse than marijuana, alcohol is legal, so marijuana should be legal too. The first premise ranks two drugs with completely different harms, and the conclusion does not follow from it either way. SAM president Kevin Sabet has answered the question the same way for more than a decade.
Culture, not safety
“Alcohol is not legal because it’s safe. Any public health person would acknowledge alcohol is a disaster. Alcohol is legal because it’s been a fixed part of Western civilization for millennia. Marijuana has not been.”
Kevin Sabet, Westword, 2017
Alcohol is woven into religion, cuisine and ceremony going back to antiquity. That is not an argument that it is good for us. It is the reason a free society cannot un-ring the bell.
The headlights and the taillights
“That’s like saying my headlights are broken, and just to be consistent, I’m going to break my tail lights, too.”
Kevin Sabet, UnHerd, 2025
Consistency is not a public health goal. If alcohol is the broken headlight, the answer is to fix what we can about alcohol, not to add a second addictive industry alongside it.
Why repeal was inevitable, and why that does not apply to marijuana
“It’s very difficult to prohibit something that 60 to 70 percent of the population are doing on a regular basis. Marijuana is still used by fewer than 10 percent of the population monthly.”
Kevin Sabet, Westword, 2017
Those figures were from 2017. The federal survey now puts past-month alcohol use at 46.6 percent of Americans 12 and older and past-month marijuana use at 15.4 percent. The gap is still three to one, and the point stands: a society can live with a drug it cannot remove. It does not have to invite a new one in.
Two wrongs
“Two wrongs don’t make a right. With alcohol and tobacco, that ship has sailed, but with pot, it’s in our hands.”
Kevin Sabet, CBS Philadelphia, 2014
Alcohol and tobacco are the cautionary tale. Both are legal, both are commercialized, and both are among the leading preventable causes of death in the United States. Legalization advocates are asking to build the third.
This is the model legalization advocates want to copy
Alcohol’s death toll is not proof that it is the worse drug. It is proof of what commercialization does. When an addictive drug is legal, advertised and used by most adults, its harms multiply. That is the story of why alcohol kills so many, and it is the model being proposed for marijuana.
Deaths from excessive alcohol use, United States
Average annual deaths, two-year periods
A 29.3 percent increase in five years. The CDC estimates each of these deaths shortened a life by an average of 24 years.
The bill
None of this is an argument for prohibiting alcohol. It is the strongest argument there is against commercializing another intoxicant. A legal, taxed, regulated, advertised drug with an industry behind it is what alcohol already is. The result is on this page.
Alcohol is in the culture. Marijuana is in the minority.
Prohibition did not fail because alcohol was harmless. It became unsustainable because most adults drank and kept drinking. That is the difference between a drug a society has to live with and one it can still choose not to commercialize.
Who uses what, past month
Share of Americans 12 and older, 2024
134.3 million Americans drank in the past month. 44.3 million used marijuana. Three to one.
Adults who say they drink versus adults who smoke marijuana
Gallup, national adults
versus
The lines are moving in opposite directions: drinking is falling as the health evidence sinks in, while marijuana use climbs with commercialization. 51 percent of Americans now say even one or two drinks a day is bad for your health.
What Prohibition actually did
Economists who went back to the data found that repeal was driven by culture and politics, not by evidence that the law made things worse
Sabet made the same point to UnHerd in 2025: Prohibition was unsustainable because alcohol is “ingrained in Western civilization, since before the time of the Old Testament.”
Marijuana is not in that position. Fewer than one in six Americans used it in the past month. The right comparison for marijuana is not alcohol in 1933. It is tobacco in 1960: a product whose industry was about to spend decades and billions normalizing it before the country understood the cost. SAM’s tagline is preventing another Big Tobacco for a reason.
Different drugs, different harms
Ranking alcohol against marijuana does not make sense, because they hurt people in different ways. Alcohol damages the liver and the heart and kills on the road. Marijuana damages the brain: it causes psychosis and schizophrenia, which alcohol does not, and today’s high-potency product is not the plant of the 1970s.
Psychosis
Odds of a first psychotic episode compared with never-users
Di Forti et al., The Lancet Psychiatry, 2019 (11 sites across Europe and Brazil). Read more on marijuana and mental health.
Potency
Average THC in samples analyzed for the federal government
National Institute on Drug Abuse. Concentrates sold in legal states commonly exceed 60 percent THC.
Heart attack and stroke
Higher odds among daily users, 434,104 adults
Jeffers et al., Journal of the American Heart Association, 2024
Addiction
Alcohol does not cause psychosis or schizophrenia, and alcohol’s potency has not quadrupled in a generation. Marijuana does both. Each drug carries its own dangers, and a side-by-side ranking tells you nothing about whether to commercialize the second one. See marijuana addiction and the Legalization Impact Report for what legal states have recorded.
Legal marijuana does not replace drinking. It stacks on top of it.
The most hopeful version of the alcohol argument is that people would swap a worse drug for a better one. The research on actual behavior points the other way.
Most marijuana users also drink
A review of the co-use literature found that more than three quarters of people who use marijuana also drink alcohol, and that using both together is linked to more consequences than either alone.
Both at once, behind the wheel
People who use alcohol and marijuana at the same time had roughly double the odds of drunk driving compared with people who drank only, in a national survey analysis. More on marijuana and driving.
Subbaraman and Kerr, Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research, 2015
And legalization made it more common
Columbia University researchers found that simultaneous use of alcohol and marijuana rose in states after they legalized recreational marijuana, relative to states that did not. Gallup’s 2026 survey likewise finds marijuana use is higher among Americans who also drink. The honest caveat: studies that look only at total alcohol sales after legalization are mixed, and some find small declines. What they do not find is the large-scale substitution the argument promises.
Columbia Mailman School of Public Health, 2022; Gallup, 2026; Calvert and Erickson, Journal of Cannabis Research, 2021 (mixed findings)
Alcohol already shows what “tax and regulate” buys
If alcohol is the template, look at the ledger. The revenue has never come close to the cost.
“For every $1 in state and federal revenue from alcohol and tobacco taxes, America spends more than $10 in social costs.”
Kevin Sabet, The Christian Science Monitor, 2013
The CDC’s own figure for excessive drinking alone, $249 billion in a year, is about $2.05 for every drink sold. No excise tax in the country comes close to that.
Marijuana is following the same curve
Marijuana excise taxes have never been more than 1.5 percent of any state’s revenue, while the costs of emergency care, impaired driving, treatment and enforcement keep arriving.
SAM, Marijuana Legalization Impact Report; Centennial Institute, Colorado cost analysis
Alcohol also answers the “regulation ends the black market” claim. A century after repeal, bootlegging is gone, but the public health harms are not. Legal states show the same pattern with marijuana: an illicit market that persists alongside the legal one, and a commercial industry that behaves the way alcohol and tobacco companies behave, because it is often the same companies.
How we got here
- 1920National Prohibition takes effect under the 18th Amendment. Consumption falls sharply, then partly rebounds as enforcement erodes. (Miron and Zwiebel)
- December 5, 1933The 21st Amendment repeals Prohibition after 13 years. (U.S. Constitution)
- 1937The Marihuana Tax Act restricts marijuana nationally. (U.S. Customs and Border Protection)
- 1970The Controlled Substances Act places marijuana in Schedule I. (21 U.S.C. 812)
- 2012Colorado and Washington vote to legalize recreational sales. SAM is founded the following year.
- 2024 to 2026Gallup records the lowest share of Americans who drink, 54 percent, and the highest share who smoke marijuana, 17 percent. Seven of ten recreational legalization ballot measures since 2022 have failed. (Gallup; SAM Impact Report)
Youth marijuana use is not a flat line
Past-month use, Americans ages 12 to 25
Use fell by more than two thirds between 1979 and 1992 as public attitudes hardened and prevention expanded, then climbed again as normalization spread. Policy and culture move use. That is the whole argument.
Johnson et al., BMC Public Health, 2020, analysis of national survey data
Why is alcohol legal but not weed? Common follow-ups
Isn’t alcohol more dangerous than marijuana?
The question ranks two drugs that hurt people in different ways. Alcohol damages the liver and the heart and kills on the road. Marijuana causes psychosis and schizophrenia, which alcohol does not, addiction in about one in three past-year users, and lasting harm to the developing brain. Alcohol’s 178,000 deaths a year are not evidence that it is the worse drug. They are what happens when an addictive drug is legal, commercialized and used by most adults. Commercializing marijuana magnifies its harms the same way.
If alcohol is legal, isn’t it hypocritical to oppose marijuana legalization?
No. Alcohol is legal because it has been part of Western culture for thousands of years and more than half of adults drink; a country cannot realistically remove it. Marijuana is used monthly by about 15 percent of Americans. Choosing not to build a new commercial addiction industry is not hypocrisy. As Kevin Sabet puts it, a broken headlight is not a reason to break the taillight too.
Didn’t Prohibition prove that banning a drug does not work?
Prohibition cut drinking sharply at first and reduced cirrhosis deaths by an estimated 10 to 20 percent, according to economists who studied the period. It ended because most Americans drank and would not stop, which made the law unsustainable. That is a lesson about the limits of banning something the majority already does, not about marijuana, which the large majority of Americans do not use.
Wouldn’t legal marijuana reduce drinking?
The evidence does not show meaningful substitution. More than three quarters of marijuana users also drink, simultaneous use rose in states after they legalized recreational marijuana, and using both together roughly doubles the odds of drunk driving. Studies of total alcohol sales after legalization are mixed. What they do not show is people giving up alcohol for marijuana at scale.
Does SAM want to bring back alcohol prohibition?
No. SAM supports evidence-based alcohol policy such as enforcement of impaired driving laws, limits on marketing to young people and taxes that reflect social costs. Our point is that alcohol shows what a legal, commercialized, addictive drug industry does to public health, and that the country should not create another one.
What does SAM support instead of legalization?
Decriminalizing possession so no one goes to jail for personal use, expanding prevention and treatment, keeping commercial sales and advertising off the table, and holding the industry to account where it already operates. The full set of positions is in our arguments against marijuana legalization.
More: SAM frequently asked questions · Arguments against marijuana legalization · Legalization Impact Report
The lesson of alcohol is not to repeat it
SAM is a bipartisan alliance of scientists, doctors and policy leaders working to prevent another Big Tobacco. Read the evidence, then help us make the case in your state.

